top of page
  • Black Facebook Icon

PAY EQUITY: FAIRNESS, HUMAN RIGHTS AND THE RULE OF LAW

7 hours ago
2 min read

BPW NZ welcomes the High Court's decision declaring that the Equal Pay Act 1972, as amended in May 2025, is inconsistent with the right to freedom from sex discrimination under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990.

It is important to understand the significance of this decision. Identifying inconsistencies between legislation is absolutely the proper role of the judiciary. The Court has not overturned the amended legislation; it has identified a legal conflict that now requires Parliament to consider and resolve. This is not judicial interference in Parliament's work – it is the rule of law operating as it should.

As Dame Marilyn Waring, who convened the independent People's Select Committee on Pay Equity, observed:

"It's been such a clear decision that this was all about the money, and money that was not saved anyway, that was then spent on other things in the budget.

You're always pleased when finally human rights are acknowledged but it's always such a sorry state of affairs that a government puts you in this position."

The independent People's Select Committee has completed its extensive inquiry, receiving almost 1,400 substantive submissions. Its findings and recommendations are available to inform Parliament's debate. Legislators now have an opportunity – and a responsibility – to use this evidence to develop a fair, effective and accessible process for resolving pay equity claims.

We must also challenge the assumption that pay equity is simply a cost.

Market forces alone cannot reliably correct the historical undervaluation of work traditionally undertaken by women. Employers face constant pressure to reduce costs, and labour is often their largest operating expense. Without a

n effective mechanism to recognise the true value of this work, existing inequalities risk being perpetuated.

There is also a compelling economic argument for fair pay. PSA analysis of Treasury's MATAI economic modelling estimates that pay equity settlements could, over four years:

  • Generate $13.5 billion in additional GDP.

  • Create approximately 13,000 additional jobs.

  • Generate $5 billion in additional government tax revenue.

The estimated net fiscal cost, after additional tax revenue, is $6 billion over four years.

Fairer wages put money into household budgets and local communities, supporting businesses, generating economic activity and reducing financial hardship and reliance on government assistance. This is an investment in people and the wider economy, not simply an expense.

BPW NZ calls on Parliament to address the legal inconsistency identified by the High Court, take account of the independent Select Committee's findings, and restore a fair and sustainable process for resolving pay equity claims.

Women working in traditionally undervalued occupations should not have to wait another generation for their contribution to be properly recognised.

Fair pay is not a privilege. It is a matter of equity, dignity and human rights.

BPW NZ | Business and Professional Women New Zealand

 
 

Recent Posts

See All
VP Issues - Sherryll Nov 26

Kia koutou, As we wind down for the year, await the outcome of our new Government's make-up, and begin looking ahead to 2027, it is a good time to consider what the year might hold for BPW NZ from an

 
 
bottom of page